


Notice the wording in the compendium, it doesnt say "Use a bow for a clean kill" it says "The most effective way to hunt them is with small arrows" it's phrasing reveals that they don't expect you to be able to do it, it's just telling you that when one hunts this animal, this would theoretically be the best way. on a boat following the bank heist that went wrong. Guarma plays a big role in Chapter 5 of Red Dead Redemption 2s story, as the main characters become stranded on the fictional island after fleeing the U.S. The only reason to bother shooting any animals on Guarma is for the exclusives to complete the compendium - parrots, the booby, and the snakes. A glitch makes it possible to access Red Dead Redemption 2’s Guarma even after the story moves on from the tropical island.

So just fire away with any weapon (But dont waste rifle ammo since its the only one not stocked at the camp, you may need it for the Dutch mission) The only thing you can take off Guarma are small things like feathers and meat. It doesn't matter because you have no horse and there's no trapper or merchants, so you cant take any pelts. How am I supposed to hunt the exotic animals properly? According to the compendium I should be using a bow to kill animals in Guarma, the problem is there's no bow in Guarma.
